The Hybrid Car Is Dead. Long Live The Hybrid Car!

/, Reviews, Road Test Reviews/The Hybrid Car Is Dead. Long Live The Hybrid Car!

The Hybrid Car Is Dead. Long Live The Hybrid Car!

It’s been months since I actually drove the 2011 Lexus CT200h. Well past the industry-standard thinking period. Well past the point of reason to write a relevant review. This does not escape me. The problem has been I didn’t know what to think of the car. There was no nice little box to fit it into and no cutesy or convenient metaphor to apply. I think the reason for the writer’s block is the car represents a tipping point in the young history of the hybrid car. It’s not that the CT200h is a good car or a bad car, but it’s a car pointing to a future where the word “hybrid” is meaningless, and that future is sooner than you think.
Think about the word “hybrid” for a minute. ‘Booo!’ ‘Hiss!’ right? It conjures images of a motoring society that’s been desaturated. Worse than beige, gray. Utterly devoid of character and interest, totally isolated from any pretense of enjoyability. Transportation appliances capable of adding nothing to your day, no more than Bluetooth extensions of your cell phone — Beeping when you swerve over a dotted line, beeping when you back up, beeping when you blink too long, beeping when the traction control steps in, beeping when you accelerate too hard or brake too hard or think about exceeding the speed limit. That is no future for the car.


Such is the perception, the doom-and-gloom place every gear head worth his salt goes when recoiling in horror at the sales figures of the Toyota Prius or ridiculing transparent grabs for green ink with the latest disappointing Honda. I do not believe this is an indication of things to come, however.
I believe the story of the hybrid will and is playing out just like the story of all new technologies in the automotive field. The newest features are pushed by marketeers as the must have game-changing something-or-other that will remake the automotive landscape forever. Sure there are some hiccups (a few car fires, some recalls, atrocious reliability, terrible quality, goofy features and questions of necessity, etc) but eventually technological evolution, cost reductions, and innovation move things in the right direction. Think of it as natural selection for cars. Once-premium features go down-market and then become just another feature. Don’t believe me? How about a few examples:
Begin at the beginning:

  • The car
  • The enclosed cabin
  • Electric lighting
  • Heaters
  • Automatic transmissions
  • The electric starter
  • Laminated safety glass
  • Air conditioning
  • Seat belts
  • Plastic bumpers
  • Crumple zones
  • Air bags
  • Electronic fuel injection
  • Stability and traction aides
  • GPS/infotainment systems

The examples are myriad, but I think you get the point. Technology and innovation aren’t something to be feared, they’re something to be refined, embraced, and integrated into the definition of the car. The good ideas by nature evolve and the bad ones die out. Nobody jumped to copy the first-generation Mazda MX-6’s oscillating vents. A counter argument is always ‘But I just want a simple car.’ Right, but we can all agree the general consumer isn’t going to march out and buy an open top, hand-crank Model T, that’s about as simple as it gets. As the consumer gains sophistication, so too must the products.
Ever drive a Ford Fusion hybrid? It’s just okay. How about that ever-present Prius? It’s a bad car. A Lexus RX hybrid? Napworthy. Dangerously so. Honda Insight? What’s the point? The reality is you’d be hard pressed to find any review of a hybrid — ever —  that doesn’t include a variation on the phrase “it’s okay… for a hybrid.” This includes the $100k-plus image hybrids that do nobody any good at all. Accepting a bad product just because it has the latest must-have feature doesn’t fly with me. It smacks of consumers being lazy and not demanding more.
And now after over 600 words I get to the point. Soon the hybrid car will no longer be acceptable as a bad car. In fact the word “hybrid” won’t even be relevant any more. “Hybrid” will just be a part of the daily operating condition of your car. The Buick LaCrosse with eAssist is fitted with stop-start, a regenerative braking system and a small battery, but they aren’t calling it a hybrid. The latest BMW M3 has stop-start, is that a hybrid? Yes and no. You see, the hybrid of the future — the very near future I believe — will go by another more familiar name: the car.
If the new Lexus I’m circuitously reviewing is any indication, the future of the hybrid is dead and the future of the car is just fine. As time goes on and fuel economy requirements grow ever stronger, pretty much everything will be getting a form of hybridization. Based on discussions with Toyota, Hyundai, GM, Ford, and other manufacturers, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a car that isn’t at least mildly electrified within two product cycles.This is not a bad thing. It’s just a change in the way things are done — a change for the better I might add.
Lets talk Toyota and Lexus real quick. I’m of the opinion the Hybrid Synergy Drive logo has so far been a free pass to sell a bad car. It’s the most cynical kind of bunt there is — create a brand, capitalize on that brand, and cruise on the brand recognition without significantly advancing the state of the art. If you want an example of where that leads, check out Sony and the Walkman. I do not like the Prius — it lacks polish, it handles like garbage, its HMI is infuriating and it asks buyers to pay a premium for a cheap-feeling interior. Hybrids Camry and Highlander? The sales figures tell that story. The HS250h is worse, it’s a tarted up Corolla without the fuel economy benefit of the Prius and fatter price tag. We’ve already discussed the RXNaptime-h and the LSGreenWash-h.
The CT200h, however, offers a surprising breath of fresh air. First, it doesn’t look like a robot egg — a big plus. You might not dig the look, but it’s nicely packaged, it has a distinctive style, and it doesn’t lull you to sleep on dulcet tones of apathy. Also, you cannot argue with wagony goodness. Second, it doesn’t handle like it’s on glare ice. Low rolling resistance tires are a bane upon the Hoon’s existence. They suck the life out of any corner and spit it into the ditch. Normally. Somehow the CT200h manages to corner confidently, albeit with the tires howling the whole way. There’s actual steering feel. Weird, I know. Its brakes aren’t squishy and vague.

There’s some kind of serious black magic going on under the hood too. For what is essentially a hot version of the Prius drivetrain, this car has some guts to it. The normally feckless electric motor is tweaked with better power electronics and develops much better torque and is combined with the Atkinson-cycle 1.8-liter VVT-i which produces 134 hp. In “Sport mode” (it also has Eco and Normal) the car has pickup you don’t expect from a hybrid, and the down-low electric grunt will wind the car from 0-60 mph in 9.8 seconds. The CVT is still unpleasant on many levels. These figures should result in cries of ‘that’s rubbish’ but I counter by saying 55 mpg economy figures were nearly effortless and 62 mpg wasn’t too much more trouble. The official EPA rating is 43/40. It’ll also do 1.2 miles in all-electric at speeds up to 28 mph. On top of it all the interior is a place fit for grown-ups and is both comfortable and stylish. Toyota’s HMI system is still deficient but hey, baby steps.
So what am I saying? The Lexus CT200h proves to me the electrified internal combustion engine is nothing to fear. There have been some bumps in the road, and a lot of bad and pointless cars along the way (Escalade Hybrid anyone?). There is still a lot of work to be done refining the systems involved, but we’re getting there and in the end we’ll all be better off. I know this sounds like sacrilege, but I’m beginning to believe it. Automakers are just starting to turn the corner and when everything is properly sorted out, cars will be just as fun and just as fast, but more frugal and maybe even a little more interesting (electric torque vectoring? through-the-road hybrid AWD?). I was going to say the CT200h is the first production hybrid I don’t feel like I have to make excuses for, but that’s not quite true. It is amongst the very few that feels like a homogeneous, finished product.  It needs regular tires and the CVT is, has, and always will be a transmission for losers, but other than that, there isn’t much to complain about. It’s a good car, no matter how late this review is.

By |2011-03-25T14:00:07+00:00March 25th, 2011|Lexus Reviews, Reviews, Road Test Reviews|25 Comments

About the Author:

25 Comments

  1. Black Steelies March 25, 2011 at 2:28 pm - Reply

    I've seen the ad for this when it's crawling all over the folding roads like a scene out of Inception.
    I thought to myself, "Whoa that's a sharp looking little wagon", then "Oh and it's a Lexus? I usually find them pretty… meh", and finally "AND it's a hybrid? Hmm, a hybrid car that Impressed me through the television screen. No doubt a first."

    • Ben March 25, 2011 at 2:45 pm - Reply

      What's funny is I took that top shot all the way back in *November*
      Now they come out with that ad campaign and it looks like some kind of press release shot.

      • Black Steelies March 25, 2011 at 3:20 pm - Reply

        I was thinking that!
        Perhaps Inception really is at play haha.

  2. muthalovin March 25, 2011 at 2:34 pm - Reply

    Price?
    Seems like a nice enough car, for a hybrid, and if I was in the market for a Lexus Hybrid (which, curiously, I am totally not) I would take mine in brown:
    <img src="http://browncar.tumblr.com/photo/1280/4076041934/1/tumblr_lild38im801qzhb89&quot; width=500>
    Photo via Brown Car Blog http://browncar.tumblr.com/post/4076041934/2011-l

    • Ben March 25, 2011 at 2:43 pm - Reply

      Starts at $29k. It's their new entry level offering, undercutting the HSh.

  3. Black Steelies March 25, 2011 at 3:22 pm - Reply

    "Oh he went full on hybrid that time."
    Cannot wait for this to become a usable catchphrase. For what, who cares?

    • Ben March 25, 2011 at 3:44 pm - Reply

      You never go full hybrid.

  4. Number_Six March 25, 2011 at 3:47 pm - Reply

    Ben, you must have driven it on completely smooth roads because I've ridden in one and the ride was simply dreadful. Like the styling, really like the interior; not paying $40KCAD for a hobby-horse. That ought to have stuck in your memory for a bit.

    • highmileage_v1 March 25, 2011 at 4:17 pm - Reply

      I think Ben lives in a place that doesn't have frost heaves and potholes that can eat a car whole. Lucky man!

      • Ben March 25, 2011 at 4:50 pm - Reply

        I live in Detroit.
        The test drive, oddly enough, happened in DelRay Beach, Florida. I will never understand media drives for cars aimed at performance or youth segments being done in south Florida, home of the elderly and the straightest, flattest, most boring roads in the country.

        • highmileage_v1 March 25, 2011 at 5:06 pm - Reply

          I found trying to survive on the Palmetto in Miami to be fairly exciting…
          I hope you had the opportunity to wallow in the corporate trough for a while?

  5. PowerTryp March 25, 2011 at 3:54 pm - Reply

    Oh crap! Guys we've got a situation H on our hands here. Bens come down with hybrid stockholm syndrome. I'll capture him, Scroggs you get as much vintage racing footage as you can, we'll take him to UDMan's place and hold him there untill the evil has been washed from his mind… Uhh we'll make this pot luck every one bring what ever you can to cure ben of the mental disease he's come down with.

    • Ben March 25, 2011 at 4:09 pm - Reply

      I own a total of 1175 hp. I think I'll be fine.

      • PowerTryp March 25, 2011 at 5:34 pm - Reply

        True, you've got that awsome red LCF flat deck. I was just really hoping to have a Hooniverse pot luck.

        • Ben March 25, 2011 at 5:37 pm - Reply

          Actually, that 1175 doesn't count the truck. The Hooniverse pot luck ain't a bad idea though.

  6. From_a_Buick_6 March 25, 2011 at 4:23 pm - Reply

    "The CVT is, has and always will be a manual transmission for losers." That just made me smile on what's been an awful, awful day.
    Ben, that was a fantastic review. Thoughtful, insightful and clearly written by a engineer/gearhead. Proof positive why (REDACTED) is so sorely lacking in your absence.
    Moreover, I'm no fan of hybrids and Toyotas leave me very cold, but this…I don't hate it. Helps that it looks like a normal hot hatch, instead of having that same mutant 1984 Honda CRX glass hatch that every other hybrid has beaten to death.

    • BrianTheHoon March 25, 2011 at 5:34 pm - Reply

      Um, I haven't been here in a while. Hoons are back to calling that other place "[REDACTED]" again? I thought "things" were patched up. Guess not?

      • From_a_Buick_6 March 25, 2011 at 6:33 pm - Reply

        I don't know if that's still SOP over here, but every time Jack Baruth bashes them over at TTAC, Roy Wort shows up to defend the farm and belittle the commenters. I'm afraid if I say (REDACTED), it'll show up in Google and Roy will come running to point out my grammatical errors.
        But no, I don't go there anymore. The content quality is gone.

        • Lex March 26, 2011 at 12:15 pm - Reply

          I've grown to look forward to his Wortiness's petty rants and attacks on all those who might question the greatness of a place promoting the ideal of "Drive free or die." I still haven't figured out what that means, but whatever.

  7. highmileage_v1 March 25, 2011 at 4:23 pm - Reply

    We have a Subie with a CVT and I thought I would hate it. However I have been pleasantly surprised. It is smooth and enables truly astounding highway mileage. Sporty? No. Competent? Yes. One noticeable thing is the turbine-like whine, but that just reminds me of a CF-6 winding up.
    Excellent write up by the way.

  8. mdharrell March 25, 2011 at 4:37 pm - Reply

    "…the CVT is, has, and always will be a transmission for losers…."
    HEY! Hey, wait just a darned minute here! I've got a couple of those
    <img src="http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1412/4732772669_6986f7f583.jpg&quot; width="300">
    and I'm not a, well, that is, not much of a…. Sigh. Never mind. I withdraw my objection.

    • Ben March 25, 2011 at 4:44 pm - Reply

      I'll happily make an exception for the weird and wonderful. I was primarily aiming that remark at cars that would be considered mainstream offerings.

      • mdharrell March 25, 2011 at 5:11 pm - Reply

        That's okay– you were right the first time. The CVT is a weak aspect of both vehicles. Its biggest drawback in the KV is that it robs a fair fraction of what little power is available in the first place (though the rollers don't help here, either), but it's even worse in the HMV: The factory manual itself warns that the CVT makes it essentially unusable in slick conditions, since the rear wheel will quickly speed up at constant throttle whenever it loses traction, which can be disastrous in a tadpole-configuration three-wheeler when the wheel grabs again. I suppose a fancy new computer-controlled traction monitoring system would help here, but that's not happening.

  9. engineerd March 26, 2011 at 8:01 am - Reply

    I knew it would only be a matter of time before car companies realized that hybrid cars that have that as their main selling point will need to be something more than crapboxes on wheels. It seems Toyota/Lexus are starting to come around.
    I hate hybrids. I hate them because they are sold as something "green" and carry a smugfactor for that reason. Their owners seem to think that because they use less gas they are somehow doing the earth a service. Never mind the strip mining for lithium and the relatively limited life of the batteries. HOWEVER, if you are looking just at fuel economy and you aren't buying the car for some green cred, then a hybrid isn't all that horrible. Of course, the premium you pay for a hybrid usually doesn't make economic sense for just gas savings, which brings me back to the green cred thing.
    But, if there is to be any glimmer of hope in the future of automania this might just be it. As dim as it is.

  10. Lex March 26, 2011 at 12:20 pm - Reply

    Excellent review and philosophical treatise on our hybridized future.
    I agree with engineerd above, the green cred pomposity is what pisses me off about hybrids. I'm also not so sure that they'll be the silver bullet (along with full electrics) that government, activists and the industry advertise. I'm under the impression that there's no such thing as a free lunch.

Leave A Comment